Sex Talk, Friendship Breakups, and Spotify’s Biggest Bet
Call Her Daddy (launched October 2018) became podcasting’s most controversial success through explicit sex advice and unapologetic female desire. Original hosts Alexandra Cooper and Sofia Franklyn’s chemistry—discussing hookup strategies, sexual positions, and dating manipulation—built “Daddy Gang” cult following among Gen Z/millennial women. The show challenged taboos around women discussing sex transactionally, though critics argued it reinforced misogyny through internalized male gaze.
The May 2020 public implosion—Cooper vs. Franklyn vs. Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy—became podcasting’s messiest divorce. Contract disputes, leaked DMs, and former best friends airing grievances across social media captivated audiences. Cooper retained the IP; Franklyn launched Sofia with an F. The drama proved that parasocial relationships with podcast hosts generated engagement rivaling reality TV.
Spotify’s subsequent $60 million exclusive deal with Cooper (2021, renewed 2024 for $100+ million) marked podcasting’s highest payout to a female creator. Cooper evolved the show from sex advice to celebrity interviews (Miley Cyrus, Hailey Bieber) while maintaining explicit edge. Call Her Daddy demonstrated that women’s sexual frankness—commercially successful but culturally polarizing—could command nine-figure valuations in podcasting’s platform wars.
Sources: