Crime Junkie, launched in December 2017 by Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat, became one of the most popular true crime podcasts, regularly topping charts and building a devoted fanbase despite plagiarism controversies.
The Format
Weekly episodes follow a consistent structure:
- Ashley narrates the case
- Brit provides reactions and questions (“Wait, what?”)
- Episodes typically 30-60 minutes
- Focus on lesser-known cases alongside famous ones
- “Pruppet of the Month” pet adoption segment
Explosive Growth
- Reached #1 on Apple Podcasts by 2019
- Spawned audiochuck media company
- Created spin-off podcasts (Supernatural with Ashley Flowers, Red Ball)
- Built massive social media following (2M+ Instagram)
- Fan Club membership offers bonus content
2019 Plagiarism Scandal
Multiple episodes were removed after allegations Flowers copied smaller podcasters’ scripts without credit. The controversy:
- Sparked debates about podcast ethics and sourcing
- Led to more rigorous citation practices
- Temporarily dented but didn’t destroy the podcast’s popularity
Cultural Impact
#CrimeJunkie became synonymous with Monday releases and water cooler discussions. The podcast:
- Introduced millions to unsolved cases
- Partnered with families of victims
- Raised money for various crime-related charities
- Made “full body chills” a catchphrase
Community
Crime Junkie fans call themselves “Crime Junkies” and engage in active Reddit/Facebook communities discussing cases, sharing theories, and supporting advocacy work.
Sources: