Fresh pet food delivery services like The Farmer’s Dog, Ollie, and Nom Nom disrupted the pet food industry starting around 2015, promoting human-grade ingredients and customized portions while charging premium prices ($3-$12/day vs. kibble’s $1-$2).
The Kibble Backlash
These companies capitalized on growing pet humanization and distrust of conventional pet food following recalls and ingredient controversies. Marketing emphasized “human-grade,” “fresh,” “customized,” and “vet-formulated” messaging, positioning kibble as processed junk food. The services offered personalized meal plans based on age, weight, and health conditions, appealing to owners treating pets as family members.
Instagram Aesthetic Marketing
Fresh pet food proved extraordinarily photogenic: colorful vegetables, fresh meat, and portioned containers created Instagram-worthy content. Companies encouraged user-generated content with branded hashtags and referral programs. Influencer partnerships (both human and pet influencers) drove adoption, with sponsored posts showing dogs eagerly eating fresh food versus rejecting kibble.
Economic Reality Check
Critics noted the services’ expense—$100-$400/month depending on dog size—made them accessible primarily to affluent pet owners. Some veterinarians questioned whether the benefits justified costs, noting properly formulated kibble meets nutritional needs. However, the companies’ success (The Farmer’s Dog reached $1B+ valuation by 2021) demonstrated market willingness to pay premium prices for perceived pet health improvements.
Sources: