Instacart’s long-awaited IPO (September 2023) valued the grocery delivery company at $10 billion—down 75% from its $39B pandemic peak, symbolizing the post-COVID reality check.
The IPO (September 19, 2023)
Priced: $30/share Opening: $42/share (40% pop) Valuation: $10 billion (first day) Peak valuation (2021): $39 billion
Down 75% from peak—brutal haircut reflecting delivery economics reality
The Pandemic Boom (2020-2021)
2020: COVID-19 made grocery delivery essential
- Revenue doubled
- Shoppers (contractors) surged from 200K → 500K
- $39B valuation (March 2021)
- Planned IPO for late 2021
Why it worked:
- Fear of in-store shopping
- Older/immunocompromised needed delivery
- Subscription (Instacart+) took off
- Expanded to alcohol, pharmacy
The Crash (2022-2023)
Post-vaccine reality:
- People returned to stores
- Inflation made delivery fees painful ($10+ on $50 order)
- Shopper quality inconsistent
- Competition from Walmart+, Amazon Fresh, DoorDash
Delayed IPO repeatedly: 2021 → 2022 → 2023 as valuation plummeted
Business Model Shift
Original: Commission from grocers + delivery fees + tips
2023 pivot:
- Advertising platform: Brands pay Instacart to promote products in app
- $740M ad revenue (2022) vs. $2.5B total
- Margins way better on ads than delivery
Essentially: Using shoppers as data source to sell ads (sounds familiar—Uber, DoorDash did same)
The Gig Economy Reality
Instacart shoppers:
- Independent contractors
- Average $10-17/hour (before gas/expenses)
- No benefits, no guaranteed hours
- Batch shopping (multiple orders at once)
- Heavy physical labor (shopping, loading, delivering groceries)
Shopper complaints:
- Low tips (or no tips)
- Heavy items (water, soda cases)
- Substitution stress (out of stock items)
- Long drives to delivery
Stock Performance
First day: $42 (good sign)
Within months: Drifted to $25-30 range
Reality: Pandemic winners became post-pandemic cautionary tales
The Competition
- Walmart+: Free delivery for $98/year
- Amazon Fresh: Integrated with Prime
- Target’s Shipt: (owned by Target)
- DoorDash: Expanded to groceries
- Traditional grocers: Kroger, Safeway built own delivery
Instacart advantage: Partnerships with most grocers (not locked to one chain)
Sources: