Apple’s controversial Touch Bar—a thin OLED strip replacing MacBook Pro function keys—became a symbol of form-over-function design, frustrating professionals before its quiet removal in 2021.
The Great Replacement
Unveiled October 2016 on the redesigned MacBook Pro, the Touch Bar replaced physical F1-F12 keys with a context-sensitive touchscreen strip. Apple pitched it as revolutionary: adaptive controls changing per-app, emoji insertion, video scrubbing, and Force Touch gestures. The entry $1,799 13-inch model included it; a $1,499 version kept function keys. #TouchBar reactions were immediately polarized—designers found volume/brightness sliders useful; developers and power users raged about lost tactile feedback.
Professional criticisms mounted: accidental touches while typing, no muscle memory for frequently-used keys, and app support was inconsistent. Adobe’s Creative Suite integration was decent, but terminal users and coders hated losing Escape key tactility (later models added a physical Escape). The Touch Bar required looking down rather than relying on touch—exactly what physical keyboards solved.
Innovation or Gimmick?
Apple doubled down through 2019, expanding Touch Bar to all MacBook Pro models except the $1,299 13-inch entry config. Third-party apps like BetterTouchTool added customization, with power users creating complex workflows. But mainstream adoption stalled—most users left default controls or disabled it entirely. #RIPTouchBar jokes accumulated as professionals bought older models specifically to avoid it.
The 2021 MacBook Pro redesign removed the Touch Bar entirely, replacing it with physical function keys. The announcement prompted celebration threads on Reddit and Twitter. Apple never acknowledged the Touch Bar’s failure directly, positioning the change as “responding to pro user feedback.”
The Touch Bar’s five-year run (2016-2021) represented Apple’s occasional misreading of professional users—prioritizing aesthetic innovation over ergonomic practicality. It’s now a collectible oddity, a reminder that even Apple makes design mistakes. #TouchBar discussions center on “what was Apple thinking?” and “could’ve been great with better implementation.”
https://www.theverge.com/ https://www.wired.com/ https://daringfireball.net/