True Crime Obsessed (June 2017) is a comedic true crime podcast hosted by Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle that recaps and discusses true crime documentaries. The show created the “true crime recap” format.
Format & Style
Each episode recaps one true crime documentary (from Netflix, HBO, Hulu, or film) with Patrick and Gillian providing hilarious commentary, analysis, and reactions. Their gay best friend energy, theatrical background, and genuine friendship create entertaining banter.
The show balances comedy with respect for victims — making fun of documentary tropes, investigators, and absurdities without mocking tragedy. Patrick and Gillian call out problematic elements in docs while celebrating well-made ones.
Catchphrases & Community
The show popularized phrases like “full body chills” (predating Crime Junkie’s version), “allegedly,” and segment names like “The Timeline” and “The Verdicts.” Listeners (“Obsessies”) formed a devoted community.
Growth & Expansion
By 2023, TCO had 400+ episodes covering everything from Making a Murderer to The Tinder Swindler to obscure YouTube docs. The show spawned a Patreon with bonus content, live shows, and merchandise.
True Crime Obsessed proved there was appetite for meta true crime content — discussing the docs themselves, not just the crimes.