#UnbelievableNetflix: Believing Survivors
Netflix’s miniseries about a serial rapist investigation and one victim’s ordeal became essential viewing—demonstrating how to tell assault stories with empathy and avoiding exploitation.
The True Story
Unbelievable premiered September 2019, based on ProPublica’s Pulitzer-winning article “An Unbelievable Story of Rape.” The eight-episode series followed Marie (Kaitlyn Dever), a teenager whose rape report was dismissed by police who accused her of lying.
Parallel narrative followed detectives Grace Rasmussen (Toni Collette) and Karen Duvall (Merritt Wever) investigating connected rapes years later, eventually vindicating Marie and catching the serial rapist.
The Approach
The show avoided graphic assault depictions, focusing instead on investigation procedures, systemic failures, and trauma’s aftermath. This choice—centering survivors’ experience over voyeuristic violence—felt revolutionary for crime drama.
The series examined how victim-blaming, poor police training, and societal skepticism enable serial predators while punishing survivors.
The Performances
Dever’s portrayal of Marie—confused, traumatized, and struggling to be believed—was devastating. Collette and Wever’s detective partnership showcased women supporting women and proper investigative empathy.
All three earned Emmy nominations. Collette and Wever won Golden Globes for their roles.
The Impact
Unbelievable influenced police training on sexual assault cases. Advocacy organizations used the series in educational programs about trauma-informed investigation and the neurobiology of assault.
The show joined I May Destroy You in demonstrating how to depict sexual violence responsibly—centering survivors, avoiding gratuitous imagery, and examining systemic failures.
The Legacy
Unbelievable set new standards for true crime storytelling—proving series could be compelling while treating real people’s trauma with dignity and avoiding exploitation.
Learn more: