The Last of Us Part II became 2020’s most divisive game - winning GOTY and critical acclaim while sparking massive fan backlash over story choices.
Leak & Controversy
In April 2020, major plot points leaked online. Fans were furious over Joel’s fate and playing as Abby. Review bombing and death threats toward voice actors flooded social media before launch on June 19, 2020.
Critical vs Fan Split
Critics loved it - 93 Metacritic score, GOTY 2020 at The Game Awards (beating Hades and Ghost of Tsushima). But user scores were 5.7, with fans divided on Ellie’s revenge story and forcing empathy for Abby.
Cultural Impact
The game sparked debates about player expectations, narrative risk-taking, and toxic fandom. Years later, the HBO adaptation vindicated some story choices, with fans praising the show’s handling of the material.
Related: #TheLastOfUs #NaughtyDog #PlayStation #GOTY2020 #HBO
Sources: