The net neutrality battle fought to preserve internet openness, preventing ISPs from blocking, throttling, or prioritizing content. The FCC’s 2015 Title II reclassification protected neutrality, but Trump’s FCC repealed it in 2017 amid record public opposition (22M comments). By 2023, the fight continued through state laws and renewed federal efforts.
What Is Net Neutrality?
The principle that ISPs must treat all internet traffic equally—no “fast lanes” for companies paying extra, no blocking competitors, no throttling services. Coined by Tim Wu (2003), it became rallying cry for open internet advocates.
The 2014-2015 Battle
After Verizon sued and won (2014), FCC’s prior rules were struck down. Chairman Tom Wheeler initially proposed allowing “paid prioritization”—effectively killing neutrality. Internet exploded: John Oliver’s viral segment crashed FCC website with comments, Reddit mobilized, tech companies protested.
February 26, 2015: FCC voted 3-2 to reclassify broadband as Title II “common carrier” (like phone service), establishing strong net neutrality protections. Obama tweeted support. ISPs sued and lost.
The 2017 Repeal
Trump appointed Ajit Pai as FCC chairman. Despite 22M public comments (83% opposing repeal, though millions were fake/bot-generated), Pai’s FCC voted 3-2 to repeal December 14, 2017. His Reese’s coffee mug video mocking protests went viral for wrong reasons.
Protests erupted: “Battle for the Net” day of action involved Amazon, Google, Netflix, Reddit showing “slow lane” messages. Congress used Congressional Review Act to reverse repeal (passed Senate, died in House).
State-Level Response
California, Washington, Oregon, and other states passed own net neutrality laws. ISPs sued claiming federal preemption. Courts mostly sided with states. The patchwork created compliance chaos for national ISPs.
The Doom Predictions vs Reality
Proponents warned repeal would destroy internet openness. Opponents claimed regulations strangled investment. Neither extreme materialized: ISPs didn’t implement blatant throttling (PR risks, state laws), but investment didn’t surge either. “The internet didn’t break” became talking point.
Biden FCC & Future
Biden nominated net neutrality supporters, but Senate gridlock delayed confirmation through 2023. Democrats lacked FCC majority to restore Title II. The stalemate continued as streaming, cloud gaming, and AI made bandwidth prioritization more lucrative.
Read more: