The pushback against “college for all” messaging celebrating plumbers, electricians, and welders earning more than liberal arts graduates.
Questioning College Necessity
By 2015-2018, rising student debt ($1.7 trillion) and underemployed graduates sparked “do you really need college?” debates. Trade school advocates argued electricians, plumbers, and HVAC technicians earned $50,000-80,000 without debt. Mike Rowe (Dirty Jobs) became prominent voice promoting skilled trades.
Enrollment Growth
Trade school enrollment grew 16% (2016-2020) while college enrollment declined. Welding programs, electrical apprenticeships, and diesel mechanics filled classes. The narrative: college-educated baristas versus debt-free plumbers earning six figures. Some politicians proposed expanding vocational programs and apprenticeships.
Nuanced Reality
While trade jobs paid well, they were physically demanding, injury-prone, and hard to sustain past age 60. Lifetime earnings still favored college degrees on average. But the revival highlighted college wasn’t the only path to middle-class income. By 2023, destigmatizing trades remained ongoing, with persistent “college or bust” cultural pressure.
References: